Living stories

Humanitarian Brief

Living stories for humanitarians. Each one follows a single case, crisis or decision for as long as it matters, and is updated as things change.

section id="s-verdict">

What the Court decided

The Court found that Myanmar's security forces committed three of the acts that make up genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention: killing members of the group, causing them serious bodily or mental harm, and imposing measures intended to prevent births. It did not find it established that Myanmar deliberately inflicted conditions of life calculated to destroy the group.

The finding covers the period around the 2017 "clearance operations". The 2016 operations, after which about 87,000 Rohingya fled, are treated as background.

The Court also found that Myanmar failed to prevent genocide by people acting alongside its forces, failed to punish it, and never passed the laws the Convention requires. It rejected the claim that Myanmar itself incited genocide. And it found that Myanmar broke the Court's 2020 emergency order by failing to preserve evidence: it completed at least one government base on the sites of former Rohingya villages in Maungdaw Township in 2021, and burned and destroyed what remained of at least five villages in Buthidaung Township in May 2020.

9
Judges who found Myanmar committed genocide
ICJ Press Release 2026/30
10,000
Deaths the Court found the record supports (at least)
ICJ Judgment 19 Nov 2026, paras 249-253
815,000
Rohingya in northern Rakhine State, the group targeted (about)
ICJ Judgment 19 Nov 2026, paras 374-380
1,834
Acts of rape cited by the Court (at least)
ICJ Judgment 19 Nov 2026, paras 357-372
Table: each point of the judgment, with votes (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)

How the Court found intent

Few disputed that atrocities took place. The case turned on intent: genocide requires proof of a specific intent to destroy a group, in whole or in part, as such.

The Court kept its strict test from earlier cases: when intent is inferred from a pattern of conduct, it must be "the only reasonable inference" from the facts. But it held that Myanmar's explanation, that the operations were counter-insurgency against the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA), "does not constitute an alternative reasonable inference". Nor did forcible displacement or punishment explain what the forces did.

It found that the record supports at least 10,000 deaths, about 1.2 per cent of the roughly 815,000 Rohingya in northern Rakhine State, and it cited at least 1,834 acts of rape. It said an inference of genocidal intent does not depend on proof that the perpetrators did everything they could to destroy the group.

The judges found widespread gang and mass rape and other sexual violence, and widespread extreme violence against children, and weighed both as signs of an intent to destroy the group. They held that rape can itself be an act of genocide.

Six judges dissented jointly. They accepted that the Rohingya suffered grave harm, but found that forced displacement or collective punishment remained reasonable explanations, said the majority had departed from the method the Court used in Croatia v. Serbia, read the pattern of violence far more narrowly, and doubted the weight of the UN fact-finders' reports.

Chart: Genocide Convention cases at the Court (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)

Evidence from the field

How the Court treated evidence matters for anyone who documents abuses. It found the two reports of the UN Independent International Fact-Finding Mission generally reliable, pointing to their 1,294 interviews and their corroboration by satellite imagery and witness statements, even though the Mission worked to a lower standard of proof than the Court. It gave considerable weight to the work of the UN Independent Investigative Mechanism for Myanmar because of its methods. Reports by non-governmental organisations carried less weight, and Myanmar's own official documents were treated with caution.

What Myanmar must now do

The Court ordered Myanmar to stop its ongoing breaches by passing laws that give full effect to the Convention, to investigate everyone reasonably suspected of genocidal acts in the 2017 operations and prosecute them where warranted, and to give guarantees that it will not happen again.

It also ordered restitution: allowing and helping the safe, voluntary and dignified return of displaced Rohingya and the reunification of families; returning or replacing lost property; searching for the disappeared and recovering, identifying and reburying the dead in line with Rohingya traditions; rehabilitation for the injured; and protection from discrimination and persecution. Where restitution cannot repair the damage, Myanmar must pay compensation to the Rohingya as a group and as individuals.

The Court did not set an amount. Myanmar must report within two years on what it has done, and the Court will then settle compensation in a later phase. It also held that The Gambia, though not itself injured, can claim these remedies "in the interest of the Rohingya, as a group and as individuals".

Timeline (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)

What happened in Rakhine State

In October 2016, and on a far larger scale from August 2017, Myanmar's security forces carried out what they called "clearance operations" in northern Rakhine State. The 2017 campaign of massacres, rape and arson drove more than 700,000 Rohingya across the border into Bangladesh.

It followed decades of persecution, including discriminatory laws and policies that deprived the Rohingya of nationality and citizenship, and anti-Rohingya hate speech spread widely on Facebook. In August 2018, a UN fact-finding mission found that genocidal intent could be inferred and called for Myanmar's top generals to be investigated and prosecuted for genocide. The United States formally determined in March 2022 that Myanmar's military had committed genocide.

Timeline (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)

Our reporting at the time

What The New Humanitarian, then called IRIN, reported from Myanmar and Bangladesh between October 2016 and November 2017.

Reading list: our reporting at the time (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)

Why The Gambia brought the case

The Gambia was not directly harmed. It sued under the Genocide Convention on the basis that the duty to prevent and punish genocide is owed to all states that are party to it. Backed by the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), it filed in November 2019.

Myanmar called The Gambia a mere "proxy" for the OIC. In July 2022 the Court disagreed. It was the first time a state with no direct connection to the alleged crimes had been allowed to bring a Genocide Convention case. Commentators see that ruling as opening the door to later cases such as South Africa's against Israel.

11 states later joined to argue how the Convention should be read, though they took no part in the final hearings.

Timeline (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)

Who was in the courtroom

11 states intervened on how the Genocide Convention should be interpreted. Interveners may address only the meaning of the Convention, not the facts of the case. Select a country to see what it argued.

Cards: the 11 intervening states (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)

The Court's first orders

At hearings in December 2019, Aung San Suu Kyi, then Myanmar's civilian leader, defended her country in person and told the judges that The Gambia had presented "an incomplete and misleading factual picture".

In January 2020 the judges unanimously ordered Myanmar to prevent genocidal acts, make sure its military did not commit them, preserve evidence, and report on its compliance within four months and then every six months. Separately, in November 2019, judges at the International Criminal Court had authorised an investigation, which concerns individual criminal responsibility rather than state responsibility.

Timeline (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)

A coup changes the defendant

In February 2021 the military, led by Min Aung Hlaing, seized power. The army accused of the atrocities was now running Myanmar's defence.

Its lawyers argued in 2022 that The Gambia had no right to bring the case at all. In July that year the Court rejected every one of Myanmar's objections, and the case moved on to the substance.

Timeline (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)

The Gambia's case

After written pleadings that ran from October 2020 to December 2024, final hearings were held from 12 to 29 January 2026. The Gambia's legal team, including Paul Reichler and Philippe Sands, argued that the only reasonable conclusion from the evidence is that Myanmar intended to destroy the Rohingya as a group, in whole or in part.

Its evidence included UN fact-finding reports, more than 1,200 confidential interviews, satellite imagery, verified video, and statements by Myanmar officials. 3 eyewitnesses testified in closed sessions, and an expert witness called by The Gambia, Michael Newton, was questioned by both sides and by several judges.

It argued that sexual and reproductive violence, including against pregnant women and children, amounted to genocide; that the Convention sets no minimum number of victims; and that a counterterrorism motive does not rule out genocidal intent. It also accused Myanmar of destroying evidence and ignoring the 2020 order, saying its 12 compliance reports gave "no reason to conclude" it had complied.

Timeline (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)

Myanmar's defence

Myanmar's agent, Ko Ko Hlaing, a junta minister under US sanctions since 2021, described the operations as counterterrorism after attacks by ARSA. "Clearance operations", he told the judges, is a "military term referring to counterinsurgency or counterterrorism operations".

Myanmar's lawyers argued there was no direct evidence of genocidal intent, that the UN fact-finders lacked objectivity, and that nearly all the evidence came from ARSA members or from refugees who feared the group. Myanmar said it had complied with the 2020 order and asked the Court to reject The Gambia's claims.

After the ruling

The judgment binds Myanmar. If Myanmar does not comply, The Gambia can turn to the UN Security Council, which has the power to decide on measures to give effect to an ICJ judgment but has never used it.

Myanmar has also changed. Min Aung Hlaing made himself president through elections in December 2025 and January 2026 that Human Rights Watch calls fraudulent. Since late 2023, Rohingya still in Rakhine have been caught between the junta and the Arakan Army, which now controls most of the state, and both have committed grave abuses. The order for safe return runs into that reality.

Other routes to accountability continue. The ICC prosecutor has asked for an arrest warrant for Min Aung Hlaing, and an Argentine court has issued warrants for 25 people, including him and Aung San Suu Kyi.

Timeline (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)

Why it matters beyond Myanmar

This is only the 3rd time the ICJ has ruled on the merits of a genocide claim, and the first time it has found that a state committed genocide.

How the judges handled intent, the counter-insurgency defence, sexual violence and UN fact-finding will be read closely in the 4 other Genocide Convention cases waiting at the Court, including South Africa v. Israel over Gaza.

Chart: Genocide Convention cases at the Court (drawn from the story data in the full page; not shown in this preview)
Sources for this explainer
  1. International Court of Justice, Judgment of 19 November 2026, The Gambia v. Myanmar. icj-cij.org
  2. ICJ, Summary of the Judgment of 19 November 2026 (Summary 2026/3). icj-cij.org
  3. ICJ, Press Release 2026/30, "The Court delivers its Judgment on the merits", 19 November 2026. icj-cij.org
  4. ICJ, Joint dissenting opinion of Vice-President Sebutinde, Judges Tomka, Abraham, Xue, Nolte and Judge ad hoc Kress, 19 November 2026. icj-cij.org
  5. International Court of Justice, case page and press releases for The Gambia v. Myanmar (case 178), including the Order on Provisional Measures (23 January 2020), the Judgment on Preliminary Objections (22 July 2022), orders on interventions (3 July 2024 and 25 July 2025) and merits hearings (12 to 29 January 2026). icj-cij.org
  6. ICJ, declarations of intervention and written observations of the 11 intervening states, 2023 to 2025. icj-cij.org
  7. Human Rights Watch, "World Court Finds Myanmar Committed Rohingya Genocide", 19 November 2026. hrw.org
  8. Human Rights Watch, "Questions and Answers: International Court of Justice Judgment in Myanmar Genocide Case", 3 November 2026. hrw.org
  9. Janet H. Anderson, "Genocide in Myanmar: The ICJ Faces the Evidence", JusticeInfo.net, 15 January 2026. justiceinfo.net
  10. 11KBW, "ICJ Hearing of The Gambia v Myanmar Commences Today", 12 January 2026. 11kbw.com
  11. The National, "Rohingya 'Targeted for Destruction': Myanmar Genocide Case Opens at UN's Highest Court", 12 January 2026. thenationalnews.com
  12. UN News, Myanmar's opening arguments, January 2026. news.un.org
  13. AFP via Malay Mail, "Gambia vs Myanmar: Rohingya genocide case sparks fiery defence at UN court", 16 January 2026. malaymail.com
  14. The Standard (Banjul), "Analysing Myanmar's response to Gambia's genocide allegations at the ICJ". standard.gm
  15. Global Centre for the Responsibility to Protect, "The Concluding Stage of The Gambia v Myanmar Genocide Case", 10 February 2026. globalr2p.org
  16. Impunity Watch, "Merits Hearings End in ICJ Genocide Case Between The Gambia and Myanmar", 27 February 2026. impunitywatch.com
  17. The New Humanitarian, "Genocide, hate speech and the Rohingya: key takeaways from the UN probe into Myanmar", 27 August 2018. thenewhumanitarian.org
  18. US Department of the Treasury, sanctions designations of 17 May 2021 (Ko Ko Hlaing). treasury.gov
  19. Radio Free Asia, "Argentina court calls for arrest warrant for Myanmar junta chief", 14 February 2025. rfa.org